728x90
my iParenting
From Our Sponsors
Get Pregnancy Information
e-newsletters
Sign up to receive our free weekly e-newsletters

new terms of use
new privacy policy
award-winning products
The iParenting Media Awards program helps parents find the best products for their families.

Stop the Violence: When Toddler Battles Cause Parental Wars

by Sharon Waldrop
It's a natural instinct for a parent to guard her child and for the parental radar to flash when there is a problem.

Most parents want to teach their toddlers to be kind to others, to be compassionate and sincere, to share toys and patiently wait their turn on the slide at the park, to hug instead of hit, to express anger and disappointment without hurting someone else.

But what about parents who aren't bothered by their children's violent outbursts? It's a tough call for Mary* when Alice's* toddler repeatedly hits Mary's toddler, but Alice ignores the situation. Mary can't stand back and watch her child get hurt, yet it isn't her role to discipline Alice's child. Also, if Mary ignores the situation, she is sending mixed signals to her toddler -- that hitting is acceptable, or even worse, that her child may not hit others but others may hit him. It is possible, however, for a parent to protect their child from further harm in such a situation, and to reinforce the message that hitting is not allowed. This can be done without an ugly confrontation with the other parent.

Cooperative Problem Solving
Let's look at the Mary and Alice scenario mentioned above. Mary realized, after Alice watched her toddler hit Mary's toddler for the third time, that Alice was not going to stop the behavior. Understandably, Mary cannot allow her child to be at the end of an angry clenched fist any longer, and her goal is to prevent further physical and emotional harm to her toddler. By picking up her toddler and removing him from harm, Mary has stopped the hurtful actions towards her son. However, her son is hurt both inside and outside, and those feelings need to be addressed. Mary's next step is to say to Alice, "Ben is feeling very sad right now because Max hurt him when he hit him. Can you and Max say something to make Ben feel better and can you work with me to see that this doesn't happen again?"

Hopefully, Mary has shown both her son and Alice's son that hitting is unacceptable and will not be tolerated -- and she has done so without starting an angry confrontation with Alice. In a perfect world, Alice will think twice before ignoring her son's aggression towards another toddler in the future.

It's a natural instinct for a parent to guard her child and for the parental radar to flash when there is a problem. Connie from San Jose, Calif. witnessed her toddler get the beating end of a stick swung aggressively by another toddler. The other toddler's mother did nothing during the attack. Connie grabbed the swinging stick and threw it out of arm's reach. She has since realized a different, more effective and gentle way to react. By removing her son from the situation and saying "It must have hurt when Tommy hit you like that. Tommy has a need to express his emotions right now, so let's leave him to do that by himself," Connie is able to console her son and make him realize the abuse wasn't directed at him.

Teaching Appropriate Behavior to Toddlers
"While it is normal for some toddlers to bite, hit and take toys, it is important for the parent to use these opportunities to teach appropriate behaviors," says Janet Blaweiss, MS, a Nationally Certified Counselor in Venice, Calif. "When a child lashes out at another, it is imperative that an adult step in, preferably the aggressive child's parent. But, if that parent does not step in, the other child's parent should gently remove her child from harm's way."

Strategies for Success

If a toddler is the target of another child's aggression and the parent of the aggressive child ignores the situation, the parent of the non-aggressive child should speak up. Blaweiss says, "Say something like, 'You know, I've been using time-outs with my child [when he hits], and it has really worked well for us.'" If that parent is not receptive to suggestions and the problem continues, it may be necessary to limit socializing to adults-only situations.

It is unfortunate that in extreme situations, two adult friends may have to avoid social activities that include their children if the safety and enjoyment of one child is at stake. It can be stressful and damaging to a friendship if one parent feels that the other parent is not concerned about the best interest and safety of their child. Perhaps a friend who refuses to work together to resolve an aggression issue isn't a ideal friend after all.

Toddlers, says Blaweiss, "are very egocentric and have not reached the developmental level of cooperative play. Rather, they engage in parallel play, or playing alongside each other." Because of this, one may act aggressively towards another. She recommends "time-out" as the most effective approach to teach young children proper behavior. The time out should be initiated immediately and calmly (one minute of time out for each year in the child's age), followed by a verbal explanation of the behavior that was not acceptable.

Shifting Blame
Sometimes the best intentions may anger another parent. Melanie from Alabama was strolling through a local mall with her son when another child approached him and started hitting him with a balloon. Melanie and her son walked away from the situation, yet the other child, a girl, followed them, continually hitting Melanie's son with the balloon. The girl's mother and another adult present never said a word to the girl, and Melanie suspects that this may be because the weapon was "just a balloon." When Melanie stepped between her son and the girl to block the hits the girl's mother finally said something: "Did you shove her?" -- directed at Melanie.

Cheryl from Pennsylvania lives next door to two boys who often hit her sons. The mother of the two boys is never outside when they are playing, and doesn't witness her sons hitting Cheryl's children. When Cheryl reported the hitting to her neighbor, the response was, "Well, what did your son do to mine to make him hit him?" Cheryl feels that her neighbor is in denial regarding her son's behavior. "What could my son possibly have done that would have made it OK for him to get hit?" says Cheryl.

It may be more difficult to work out toddler aggression problems with strangers at the mall and casual acquaintances than with a friend. But the situation is likely to come up sometime at a park, grocery store or any other public establishment, so you should be prepared to handle it quickly and effectively.

*Name has been changed.

About the Author: Debbie Farmer is a contributing writer for iParenting.com and a syndicated columnist. Her Web site address is http://www.geocities.com/So Ho/Lofts/2878/

back to the index